{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-022", "title": "customer economic value >=10x is NO-GO", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-023", "title": "KEM binding models are consistency checks not discoveries", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-004", "title": "R4 1379333x is projection", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-006", "title": "R6 7/7 Wi-Fi CVEs corrected to 3 families", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-007", "title": "R7 decirc speed claims corrected", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-008", "title": "R8 Actions billing block false", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-009", "title": "R9 six-engine K=7 claim corrected to four", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-010", "title": "R10 K_constr 6 corrected to 7", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-011", "title": "R11 unsound 123-line Farkas checker deleted", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": "conformance/farkas_negative_controls/{overflow_forge.txt,zero_goal_vacuous.txt}", "verification_tier": "T1", "verification_evidence": "CHECK_SRC->oss/farkas-check/src/farkas_check.c verified at tools/check_farkas_certs.py:52; both forging certs present; gate single_checker_no_fork present", "still_reproducible": true, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-012", "title": "forced-set intersection empty", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-013", "title": "identity-unbound request admitted", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-015", "title": "13 forged minhw certificates accepted before repair", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-016", "title": "24 forged BOMs and wrong citations accepted before repair", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-018", "title": "dyncap off-by-one depended on load", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-019", "title": "underclaim recall regressed to 1/3", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-021", "title": "outward hunt found zero novel breaks", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-007", "title": "counters-k3 search refuted its intended hypothesis", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-008", "title": "component floors do not add: 512 states versus joint 70", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-010", "title": "lake build alone is not a sorry/axiom gate", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-012", "title": "dyncap mem signal is a counter contrary to README", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-013", "title": "guard-advertising gate docstring false on arrival", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-017", "title": "sky130 liberty has no upstream checksum/NOTICE", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-020", "title": "unreachable manifest percent-encodes tabs", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-017", "title": "re_derived was substring search including comments", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-020", "title": "dyncap model contaminated", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-018", "title": "Phase0 URL capture regex produced run-wide false negatives", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-021", "title": "sealed registry sweep omitted folder4 package names", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-026", "title": "checkout restore leaves created files behind", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-001", "title": "R1 unconditional K>=26 and DRAT claim retracted", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-002", "title": "R2 1095743x DoS claim retracted", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-003", "title": "R3 361587x measured claim corrected", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-005", "title": "R5 2146200 evaluations retracted", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-014", "title": "redundancy probe swallowed 1400 TypeErrors", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-NEG-024", "title": "33 attack traces fail clean-clone reproduction", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-019", "title": "raw invariance runs FAIL then receive disclosed reclassification", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-023", "title": "stale pyc broke three restores", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-022", "title": "red/green anchors silently stopped applying", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}
{"failure_id": "folder4:F4B-P1-NEG-005", "title": "modelrisk check rejected the correct repaired answer", "tier": "supporting_evidence", "status": "retained_unilateral", "disposition": "retained", "negative_control_path": null, "verification_tier": "T2", "verification_evidence": "sealed registry row read; not independently reproduced this pass", "still_reproducible": false, "superseded_by": null, "anchor_sha": "90eca0748b8d50dfd7a8143a1a1f0ab138e75428", "verified_date": "2026-08-13", "preserved": true}